This must have come up a thousand times before, but y’know what? From where I stand I think it’s pretty much the only thing that is a genuine problem with this game. Everything else is tweaks and fine tuning, but there is one gaping flaw in the mechanics of Cataclysm: Dark Days Ahead that is genuinely hurting it. It’s so important that I hope the creator of the game or the coders working on it actually see this and consider it.
Space. That’s it. That’s the only thing wrong with this game. That’s all that’s keeping me from liking it, and all that’s keeping me from playing it. There is not enough space.
My last game made it painfully clear to me: my character broke her leg and was forced to flee from town, because my NPC ally was being killed by cougars and I could not stay in that area lest I join her. I had to leave my companion for dead, and when I got back to the shelter I’d been using, I realized that zombies were wandering towards it. A horde. I grabbed my shit and limped away as fast as I could, desperate to find some kind of safety.
I could not find it. Why? Because everywhere I went I was oh so carefully squeezing my way between sectors of the map in the cloak of darkness that, say, a Decayed Pouncer was lingering on, or a Bear was sitting at, or a wolf was lurking, or a coyote was stalking around, or some random-ass zombie had hobbled into. It wasn’t just the area; I left the forest and I continuously dodging between the enemy’s awareness zones, and I wasn’t comfortable sitting in the gaps I found because it was just barely out of range and come morning they’d possibly spot me and chew my other leg off. For some reason the animals refused to attack any other part of my body but my legs, and essentially if I got seen I would die. The same for any zombies. Anything would kill me and I needed respite, and it was not possible, because things were everywhere. Literally everywhere. I traveled three times the length of the starting field of vision just trying to find somewhere something else wasn’t.
And then I died. Why? Because I got run down by something faster than me, both at my current speed and base speed. And if it hadn’t been it, it’d have been some zombear. Or a cougar. Or basically anything at all. Maybe a skeleton? Dogs? Wolf pack? Take your pick, everything’s a valid choice, given the density of bodies across the entire continent.
This was something of a rare circumstance, being on the run, because I normally die when things like this happen. I can’t move anywhere and I am caught and I die. MAYBE i get ahold of something, and MAYBE i get my feet on the ground and I can defend myself, but it’s a real dice roll and the odds are NOT in the player’s favor. To me that’s far, far too much reliance on luck of the draw and how unfortunate your starting location may or may not be. And let’s not even talk about how many times I’ve been mauled to death by random crap simply stepping out the door to find a rock.
The point I’m trying to make is, this game needs (and by “need” I mean “requires in order to preserve its functionality and to ensure the player gets a fair shot and is able to actually play the game”) adjustments in the world generation code. If you did this, you could legitimately get a pretty decent grade on the game overall if you released it right then and there and never touched it again. I’ve been playing this game non stop for weeks since I picked it up and that’s the one thing that comes up again and again: space. I need space. I need peace. I need air. I need to breathe.
I really hope that someone somewhere in a position to do anything about this takes this seriously; I’ve played a lot of games that had similar world generation patterns and it just killed it for me. Factorio’s a great example: love the hell out of that game, I’m all about moving parts and systems and organizing and micro-managing factories and all that awesomeness, but everything was too close. Too cramped. Too tight. You couldn’t GO anywhere, or you didnt NEED to go anywhere, and that’s what’s driven me away from it whilst it continues to get maintained. I’m paying less and less attention to it these days, too, just cuz of that.
Basically I feel that this is something that would be much better getting looked at sooner rather than later. I hope my encouragement leads to something.