From a roleplay perspective:
Being human is the ultimate goal… The wold has gone and shifted humans down a few steps on the food chain and we’re robbing and killing one another for scraps of food and little bottles of water. If we’re lucky, an abandoned house to board up the windows in and try to start a farm. We’ve lost the war, but that doesn’t mean we’ve lost ourselves. Humanity MUST be brought back on top, or humanity will go extinct. To tweak out our humanity with mutated and bionic supplements destroys the very essence of being a human. I just don’t like the idea of sticking mechanical doofloppies into my body when the machines are already against us anyway, nor do I like the idea of my body becoming more akin to a giant frog than a human being.
From a more OOC perspective:
No downsides, perhaps. But the extra time it’s going to take me to find the books, then read them and/or the points I must burn to get the stats/skills I need to install and use them seems counter-intuitive to keeping myself alive. I hate “grinding”; if I need to use a skill and it’s going to gain me levels in that skill, great… But I don’t like to sit there and make a hoodie, (fit) it, reinforce it then cut it up for rags and do it again over and over. I admit to having had to do that on occasion to replace / reinforce doors in my base by building dressers then *-Disassembling them a few times, but I find that kind of gameplay incredibly annoying. The skills I need to keep myself fed, watered and protected defensively and aggressively will go up as I use them to keep going. Throwing knifes at a floorboard? Making an article of clothing only to cut it up again? Building furniture to just tear it back down again? Blegh… Not if I don’t have to. I want an adventure, not a repeated series of key-presses.[/quote]
…I’m not gonna deny that my perspective is more than a little biased on my opinion of how important my, or anyone else’s “humanity” is but I gotta say… I don’t think I’ve ever seen a purist argument before that didn’t just sound like prosophobia.
and then you went and completely blew that away with the
I guess my view on the situation of bionics and the moral implications are… …well quite simple.
I have very few. A tool is a tool, regardless if that tool is an integrated toolset, a digital storage medium integrated into your biological one, or a sword that flies out of your wrist. What you seem to fear, and I apologize if I’m wrong, is losing free will not your “humanity” Losing your ability to decide what you want to do with your life, and I don’t see how an Integrated Toolset, A mini-flamethrower, enhanced memory banks, etc, etc effects that free will. At the end of the day, your still in charge.
There are no bionics that replace the thought process completely, some enhance it (the dodge bionic I believe? definitely the targeting bionic) but none take it completely away. You’re simply replacing the abilities of the flesh with those of the machine.