Uh, IMO Earthbound’s system actually discouraged casual condiment use because of the randomness. Suggest having it presume efficient condiment-use, or, as Hyena Grin suggested, making condiment-use a recipe thing.
(Hmm…“jammy bread”, yeah, that’s right up with “chunk of veggy”. KEEPER. Even though it makes me think we really ought to be able to disable robots by throwing jars of jam at them. See: Spaceballs.)
Gourmand should definitely make condiments more effective.
One thing: if condiments get passively used, it should pull from the craftables-radius, not just your inventory. 