Cataclysm has a review in the latest episode of the FoSS podcast TuxJam.
http://unseenstudio.co.uk/tuxjam-ogg/tuxjam-episode-25/
Haven’t listened yet, don’t know if it’s good or bad 
Update: The review of Cata starts at 49:25.
Update2: It’s a very short first impressions review, only about 5 minutes.